IRS notice CP215 or CP15 for Form 5472: what it means and what to do
Last reviewed
The short answer
A letter that charges a Form 5472 penalty is a "Notice of Penalty Charge". The IRS manual says it is a CP 215 for penalties on a business account and a CP 15 for penalties on an individual account. It tells you the penalty, the tax year, the amount and the date to pay or answer. Your choices: file any Form 5472 that is still missing, ask for relief for reasonable cause in a signed written statement, show proof if you did file on time, pay, and appeal a refusal. First time abatement generally does not apply to this penalty. Relief is requested, never guaranteed.
Key facts
- Notice name
- Notice of Penalty Charge: CP 215 (business) or CP 15 (individual)
- Answer by
- The date printed on your notice
- Relief
- Reasonable cause, in a written statement under penalties of perjury
- First time abate
- Generally not available; one narrow exception
- After 90 days
- A continuation penalty may apply to a form still not filed
What is IRS notice CP215 (or CP15)?
People often call any IRS penalty letter a "CP15". The IRS internal manual (IRM 20.1.9, International Penalties) explains that when an international penalty is assessed, the IRS computer sends a computer paragraph notice: a CP 15, Notice of Penalty Charge, for penalties posted to an individual account, or a CP 215, Notice of Penalty Charge, for penalties posted to a business account. For the Form 5472 penalty, the manual names the CP 215. Both say the same thing: a penalty has already been charged.
The IRS page Understanding your CP215 notice puts it simply: the IRS sent the notice because it charged you a civil penalty, and you should read it carefully because it explains the due date, the amount and the payment options.
The manual describes two common ways a Form 5472 penalty is charged. It can be assessed automatically when a Form 5472 arrives attached to a late Form 1120 (IRM 21.8.2.21.2 says this assessment results in a CP 215). Or it can be assessed after an IRS examiner finds a form that was missing or incomplete. The amount and how it grows are explained in the Form 5472 penalty guide.
How to read the penalty notice
The manual's sample of a CP 215 shows the first line "We charged you a penalty", then the Internal Revenue Code section and the reason, then a table with the prior balance, the penalty, interest, other charges and the total amount owed. It also explains what to do if you agree or disagree, how to pay, and how to claim a refund.
| What to check | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Name and EIN | The notice must be for your LLC. Check the EIN against your IRS letter that gave it |
| Tax period | Each tax year is a separate penalty. Match it to the year of the Form 1120 you filed or missed |
| Code section | Section 6038A is the Form 5472 penalty |
| Amount | The penalty is $25,000 per form; the notice may add interest |
| Date | The date to pay or answer. Follow it |
| Phone number | The IRS says it is at the top right corner of the notice |
The IRS page on international information reporting penalties says to check that the information on the notice is correct and to follow its instructions. If a notice has instructions or deadlines for disputing the penalty, you must follow them.
Received a Form 5472 penalty notice: what to do first
- Keep the whole notice, with its envelope, and write down the date it arrived.
- Find your proof of filing for that year: the fax confirmation or mailing receipt, the pro forma Form 1120 and Form 5472, and any Form 7004 extension.
- List every year since the LLC was formed and mark which ones were filed. A missing year is a separate failure.
- File every Form 5472 that is still missing, complete and correct, as the Form 5472 instructions guide describes.
- Answer the notice by its date: by phone at the number on the notice, or in writing.
Step 4 comes before relief. The manual (IRM 20.1.9.5.5) recommends that reasonable cause is not considered for any year until all late returns are filed, and IRM 21.8.2.21.2 says a relief request cannot be considered until the missing returns are filed.
The choices the IRS describes
| Situation | What the IRS describes | Source |
|---|---|---|
| You filed on time, or had an extension | Dispute the penalty and send proof: fax confirmation, mailing receipt, Form 7004 | IRS penalty page |
| You filed late, or a form is still missing | File what is missing, then ask for relief for reasonable cause | IRM 20.1.9.5.5 |
| You want to pay | Pay online or by check; a payment plan may be possible. After paying you may claim a refund with Form 843 | IRS penalty page |
| Your relief request was refused | Ask for an appeal. The manual says Appeals offers a prepayment, post-assessment appeal for all international penalties | IRM 20.1.9 |
Interest is charged on penalties. The IRS reasonable cause page says that if a penalty is reduced or removed, the related interest is reduced or removed automatically.
The IRS penalty appeal page says you generally have 30 days from the date of the rejection letter to ask for an appeal, and that the letter gives the exact deadline.
Form 5472 penalty abatement: what a reasonable cause letter contains
For this penalty the manual sets a firm rule: the company must make an affirmative showing of all the facts, in a written statement with a declaration that it is made under penalties of perjury. A phone call alone is not that statement.
The IRS reasonable cause page says a request should explain:
- what happened and when it happened;
- how it prevented you from filing on time;
- what you did to try to file;
with supporting documents, such as copies of letters, receipts or forms. For a business, it says the reasons apply to the person with authority to submit the return.
Two rules pull in different directions. The IRS page says lack of knowledge and reliance on a tax professional generally do not qualify for failure to file. But for Form 5472, the manual quotes Regulations section 1.6038A-4(b)(2)(ii): reasonable cause is applied liberally when a small corporation (gross receipts of $20,000,000 or less) had no knowledge of the requirement, has limited presence in and contact with the US, and promptly and fully complies with requests to file Form 5472 and to provide books and records. Many small foreign-owned LLCs may fit those words, so a good statement describes each of them with facts.
IRM 21.8.2.21.2 tells IRS staff to ask callers who want reasonable cause relief from the initial Form 5472 penalty to send it in writing to: Internal Revenue Service, 1973 Rulon White Blvd., Mail Stop 6552, Ogden, Utah 84404. If your notice gives a different address, follow the notice. The same section says the decision on the Form 5472 penalty generally follows the decision on the related Form 1120.
Is first time abatement available for the Form 5472 penalty?
Generally, no. First time abate (FTA) is an IRS waiver for taxpayers with a clean three-year history. The Penalty Handbook, IRM 20.1.1.3.3.2.1 says it does not apply to returns with an event-based filing requirement or to information reporting that depends on another filing, and it lists Form 5472 as an example, "see IRM 20.1.9 for exception". The IRS page on administrative penalty relief lists only failure to file, failure to pay and failure to deposit penalties as eligible.
The one exception in the manual
IRM 20.1.9.5.5 allows FTA only for the penalty assessed automatically because Form 5472 was attached to a late Form 1120. That penalty may be removed under FTA if the late-filing penalty on the related Form 1120 is removed under FTA, or would have qualified but was not charged because there was no tax due, and:
- the company had no similar Form 5472 penalties in the three prior periods; and
- the related Form 1120 was not filed late in the three prior periods.
A pro forma Form 1120 shows no tax, so this exception can matter for a foreign-owned LLC. Whether a particular company meets the conditions depends on its filing history, which only the IRS's review settles. It is written only for the automatic penalty, not for one assessed by an examiner. If it does not apply, the manual says relief is still available when reasonable cause is shown.
The continuation penalty after 90 days
The Form 5472 instructions say that if a failure continues for more than 90 days after the IRS notifies you, a further $25,000 applies for each 30-day period, or part of one. The manual says there is no reasonable cause exception for this continuation penalty. The way to stop it is to file a complete and correct form. See the Form 5472 penalty calculator for how the amount grows, and the pro forma Form 1120 guide for how a late return is sent.
Common mistakes
- Ignoring the notice. The penalty stays, interest grows, and a still-missing form can lead to the continuation penalty.
- Sending a letter without filing the form. The manual says relief is not considered until all missing returns are filed.
- Filing only the year on the notice. File every missing year.
- An unsigned or vague statement. It must be written, specific, and made under penalties of perjury.
- Asking for first time abatement only. It rarely applies here; explain your reasonable cause as well.
- Missing the appeal deadline in a refusal letter.
Nobody can promise that the IRS will remove a penalty. If you want a preparer to file the missing years and write the statement, see late Form 5472 and penalty relief.
Have it prepared and filed for you
Late Form 5472 Catch-Up Filing
Missed one or more years? File now, with a reasonable-cause statement attached.
Not included: each additional missed year ($299 per year, added at checkout); responding to a penalty notice you have already received (quoted separately); any penalty the IRS assesses. Relief is requested, never guaranteed.
$499first missed year, then $299 per extra year
View service
Questions and answers
Is a CP15 or CP215 a final decision?
It is a bill for a penalty that has been charged. It also explains what to do if you disagree. You can still ask for relief, show proof of timely filing, and appeal a refusal.
Should I pay the penalty before asking for relief?
The IRS describes both paths. Paying stops further interest; you may then claim a refund with Form 843. The manual says Appeals offers a prepayment appeal for international penalties, so payment is not required to appeal. A preparer can help you decide.
Can I ask for relief by phone?
The IRS says some penalties can be reduced by phone. For Form 5472, the manual requires a written statement under penalties of perjury, and tells staff to ask callers to send their request in writing.
I filed on time by fax. Why did I get a notice?
Check the tax period and EIN first. Then dispute the penalty with a copy of the fax confirmation and the forms you sent. The IRS penalty appeal page says to send proof that you filed on time.
Does closing the LLC make the notice go away?
No. The penalty is charged to the company for a past year. See how to close a US LLC for the final filings.
Official sources used in this guide
- IRM 20.1.9, International Penaltiesirs.gov/irm/part20/irm_20-001-009
- Understanding your CP215 noticeirs.gov/individuals/understanding-your-cp215-notice
- IRM 21.8.2.21.2irs.gov/irm/part21/irm_21-008-002r
- IRS page on international information reporting penaltiesirs.gov/payments/international-information-reporting-penalties
- IRS reasonable cause pageirs.gov/payments/penalty-relief-for-reasonable-cause
- IRS penalty appeal pageirs.gov/appeals/penalty-appeal
- Penalty Handbook, IRM 20.1.1.3.3.2.1irs.gov/irm/part20/irm_20-001-001r
- IRS page on administrative penalty reliefirs.gov/payments/administrative-penalty-relief
- Form 5472 instructionsirs.gov/instructions/i5472
- Form 843irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-843
This guide explains general rules. It is not advice for your situation. Tax results depend on your facts, and a preparer reviews them before anything is filed. Check the linked official sources for the current rules.
Related guides
- The Form 5472 penalty: $25,000, and what you can do about itHow the $25,000 penalty is assessed, the continuation penalty, reasonable cause and what to do after missed years.7 min
- Form 5472 instructions: how to fill it in, part by partA part-by-part walk through Form 5472 and the pro forma Form 1120 for a US LLC with one foreign owner, with a worked example.9 min
- The pro forma Form 1120 for a foreign-owned US LLCThe cover return a foreign-owned single-member LLC files with Form 5472: what to complete and where to send it.6 min
- What is Form 5472, and who must file it?The IRS information return for foreign-owned US companies: who files it, what it reports and how it is sent.8 min