Skip to content

Private tax preparation service. Not the IRS.

USTAX
GuideUS income tax · 10 min read

Effectively connected income (ECI) vs FDAP: does a foreign owner owe US income tax?

Last reviewed

The short answer

The United States taxes a foreign person in two ways. Income that is effectively connected with a US trade or business (ECI) is taxed on the net amount, after allowable deductions, at the same graduated rates as US citizens and residents. Fixed, determinable, annual or periodical (FDAP) income from US sources that is not ECI, such as US dividends, interest and royalties, is taxed at a flat 30% of the gross amount, or a lower treaty rate, usually by withholding. Whether you have ECI depends on whether you are engaged in a US trade or business, which the IRS decides on your facts. A tax treaty can change the result.

Key facts

ECI
Net income, graduated rates, reported on a US return
FDAP (not ECI)
30% of the gross amount, or a lower treaty rate, usually withheld
US trade or business
Considerable, continuous and regular activity; decided on the facts
Form to the payer
W-8ECI for ECI; W-8BEN or W-8BEN-E for other income
Form 5472
Depends on reportable transactions, not on taxable income

What is effectively connected income, and what is FDAP income?

A foreign person here means a non-resident individual (a "nonresident alien" in IRS words) or a foreign corporation. The IRS page on taxation of nonresident aliens says the income of a non-resident that is subject to US tax must generally be divided into two categories:

  • Effectively connected income (ECI): income connected with a trade or business in the United States.
  • FDAP income: "fixed, determinable, annual or periodical" income from US sources. In plain words: payments such as interest, dividends, rents and royalties. The IRS page on FDAP income says it is all income except gains from the sale of property and a few excluded items.
ECI vs FDAP income
PointEffectively connected income (ECI)FDAP income that is not ECI
What it isIncome connected with a US trade or businessUS-source interest, dividends, rents, royalties and similar payments
Taxed onNet income, after allowable deductionsThe gross amount. No deductions
RateGraduated rates, the same as for US citizens and residents (individuals)Flat 30%, or a lower treaty rate
How the tax is paidThrough a US tax returnUsually withheld by the payer
Form you give the payerW-8ECIW-8BEN (individual) or W-8BEN-E (entity)
Return for an individualForm 1040-NR, page 1Schedule NEC of Form 1040-NR, when a return is filed
SourcesIRS: ECIIRS: FDAP

The same payment can fall in either column: the IRS ECI page says certain kinds of FDAP income are treated as ECI.

What is a US trade or business?

The IRS ECI page says a foreign person generally must be engaged in a trade or business in the United States during the tax year to treat income received in that year as ECI. IRS Publication 519 (chapter 4) says it depends on the nature of your activities. The IRS states these points:

  • Activity level. The business activities must be "considerable, continuous and regular" (IRS ECI page).
  • Personal services. If you perform personal services in the United States at any time during the tax year, you are usually considered engaged in a US trade or business. The law (26 U.S.C. 864(b)) has a narrow exception for a non-resident who works for a foreign employer, is in the United States for no more than 90 days in the year, and is paid no more than $3,000 for that work.
  • Business operations. If you own and operate a business in the United States selling services, products or merchandise, you are, with certain exceptions, engaged in a US trade or business.
  • Partnerships. A member of a partnership engaged in a US trade or business is considered engaged in it too.
  • Trading. Trading in stocks, securities or commodities through a US resident broker, as your only US business activity, is not a US trade or business, unless you have a US office through which you trade.

Once you are engaged in a US trade or business, Publication 519 says all your US-source income for the year, other than certain investment income, is treated as ECI, whether or not it is connected with that business.

For a US single-member LLC, the owner's position is what counts: the IRS page on single-member LLCs says the activities of a disregarded LLC are reflected on its owner's return. See what a disregarded entity is.

What is US source income?

The IRS page on sourcing of income says a non-resident is generally subject to US income tax only on income from US sources. The source is decided by a rule for each type of income, not by where the bank account is. The common types, from Table 2-1 of Publication 519:

Source rules for common types of income
Type of incomeWhat decides the source
Pay for services, including business income from personal servicesWhere the services are performed
Sale of inventory you boughtWhere it is sold
Sale of inventory you producedWhere it is produced
InterestResidence of the payer
DividendsWhether the paying corporation is a US or a foreign corporation
RentsLocation of the property
Royalties for patents, copyrights and similar propertyWhere the property is used
Sale of personal propertySeller's tax home, with exceptions

Each line has exceptions, set out in chapter 2 of Publication 519. Self-employed work done partly inside and partly outside the United States is often split by time.

Example: a designer in Portugal who works for clients through a US LLC earns US-source service income only for the work done while in the United States.

How is effectively connected income taxed?

The IRS ECI page says ECI, after allowable deductions, is taxed at the graduated rates that apply to US citizens and resident aliens. FDAP income gets no deductions at all.

The US LLC tax rate for non-residents

There is no separate tax rate for an LLC. A single-member LLC is disregarded for income tax by default, so its income is taxed at its owner's rates:

  • Owner is a non-resident individual: ECI at the graduated individual rates, on Form 1040-NR; FDAP at 30% or a lower treaty rate.
  • Owner is a foreign corporation: its ECI is taxed under section 11 of the tax code (26 U.S.C. 882), which sets the corporate tax at 21% of taxable income (26 U.S.C. 11(b)). The return is Form 1120-F. Other rules can apply to foreign corporations, so a preparer reviews each case.

A return can be due when no tax is due

The Form 1040-NR instructions say a non-resident engaged in a US trade or business must file even with no income from that business, no US-source income, or income that is exempt under a treaty. The Form 1120-F instructions say the same for a foreign corporation. We prepare Form 1040-NR for non-residents. We do not prepare Form 1120-F.

Are dividends and capital gains effectively connected income?

Dividends are FDAP income. A US dividend that is not ECI is taxed at 30% of the gross amount, or a lower treaty rate. Publication 519 describes two tests that can make it ECI instead: the asset-use test (assets used in the US business) and the business-activities test (the US business was a material factor in producing it). Stock of a corporation is generally not treated as an asset used in a US business.

Capital gains follow their own rule. The IRS FDAP page says a non-resident individual who was in the United States for less than 183 days in the year is not taxed on capital gains, with exceptions, including gains effectively connected with a US business. A non-resident present for 183 days or more is taxed at 30% (or a lower treaty rate) on net US-source capital gains. The IRS ECI page says gains from US real property interests are treated as ECI.

More detail: US tax on dividends and capital gains for non-residents.

US trade or business vs permanent establishment: what a tax treaty changes

The IRS page on tax treaties says residents of treaty countries may be taxed at a reduced rate, or be exempt, on certain items of US-source income, and that these rates and exemptions vary by country and by type of income.

For business income, many treaties use a different test. Publication 519 (chapter 9) says that under a treaty's business profits article, individuals can generally exempt their business profits from US tax unless they have a permanent establishment in the United States to which the profits are attributable. IRS Publication 901 says a permanent establishment generally means a fixed place of business, such as a place of management, a branch, an office, a factory, a warehouse or a mining site, and that the exact meaning depends on each treaty.

So a person can have a US trade or business and still owe no US tax on its profits under a treaty, while still filing a return. Whether a treaty applies depends on its text and your facts. A preparer reviews it.

W-8ECI vs W-8BEN, and why Form 5472 is due anyway

Payers ask for a W-8 form to decide how much to withhold. The Form W-8ECI instructions say:

  • A foreign person who receives US-source ECI gives Form W-8ECI to the payer. Withholding is generally not required on ECI, but this exception does not apply to personal services income of an individual.
  • Do not use W-8ECI to claim a treaty rate on income that is not ECI: use W-8BEN or W-8BEN-E. If one payer pays you both kinds of income, give one form for each kind.
  • A W-8ECI needs a US taxpayer identification number (SSN, EIN or ITIN) to be valid. It goes to the payer, not to the IRS.

To choose between the two W-8BEN forms, read W-8BEN vs W-8BEN-E. We prepare W-8BEN and W-8BEN-E. We do not prepare W-8ECI.

Form 5472 does not depend on tax

The Form 5472 instructions say a foreign-owned US disregarded entity has no income tax return filing requirement, but must file a pro forma Form 1120 with Form 5472 attached if it had a reportable transaction with a related party. Contributions to and distributions from the LLC are reportable. So the yearly Form 5472 filing is due whether the owner has ECI, FDAP income or no US tax at all.

Common mistakes

  • Treating "US company" as "US income". The source of each payment follows the source rules, not the state where the LLC was formed.
  • Using a rule of thumb instead of the facts. Staff, agents, an office, inventory or work done in the United States can each change the answer. See US tax for Amazon FBA sellers.
  • Assuming a treaty means no return. Treaty-exempt business income can still require Form 1040-NR or Form 1120-F.
  • Mixing up the W-8 forms: a W-8BEN for income you report as ECI, or a W-8ECI to claim a treaty rate on dividends.
  • Skipping Form 5472 because there is no tax. The penalty for not filing it is $25,000 per form (Form 5472 instructions).

Have it prepared and filed for you

  • Form 5472 + Pro Forma 1120 Filing

    The yearly IRS filing every foreign-owned single-member US LLC has to make.

    Not included: state income tax returns and state annual reports (available as an add-on); bookkeeping, if your records are not ready; prior-year (late) filings, priced separately.

    $349per LLC, per tax year

    View service
  • Form 1040-NR Non-Resident Tax Return

    Your US non-resident return prepared and e-filed by a credentialed preparer.

    Not included: state income tax return ($99 each); applying for a US taxpayer number, if you do not have one; tax due to the IRS.

    from $249per person, per tax year

    View service

Questions and answers

What is the FDAP income tax rate?

The IRS says US-source FDAP income that is not effectively connected is taxed at 30% of the gross amount, or a lower treaty rate. No deductions are allowed. The tax is usually withheld by the payer.

I run my US LLC from abroad and never travel to the US. Do I have ECI?

It depends on what the business does and where. Inventory, US staff, agents or an office can change the answer, and so can a treaty. A preparer reviews your facts before saying whether you owe US income tax.

Are dividends effectively connected income?

Generally they are treated as FDAP income, taxed at 30% or a lower treaty rate. They can be ECI if they pass the asset-use or business-activities test described in IRS Publication 519.

W-8ECI vs W-8BEN: which one do I give?

W-8ECI is for income effectively connected with your US trade or business, and needs a US tax number. W-8BEN (individuals) and W-8BEN-E (entities) are for other income, including treaty claims. We prepare W-8BEN and W-8BEN-E; we do not prepare W-8ECI.

If I owe no US income tax, do I still file Form 5472?

Yes, if your foreign-owned US LLC had a reportable transaction, such as money you put in or took out. The Form 5472 filing check tells you if it applies to your year.

Official sources used in this guide

This guide explains general rules. It is not advice for your situation. Tax results depend on your facts, and a preparer reviews them before anything is filed. Check the linked official sources for the current rules.

Sign here

Find out what you need to file. It takes two minutes.

Answer four questions about your company. You see which filings you need, the deadlines and the fixed price for each.

147
days left to file Form 5472 for tax year 2026
April 15, 2027